Landmark Medical Negligence Cases and Awards in Trinidad and Tobago

Medical-negligence compensation depends on the findings, the evidence and the losses proved in the particular case. A judgment must be read with any later appeal. The decisions below illustrate different outcomes; they do not establish a minimum payment, a ceiling or a guaranteed award for another patient.

Gulf View Medical Centre Ltd v Tesheira

In [Gulf View Medical Centre Ltd v Tesheira and Roopchand v Tesheira [2022] UKPC 38](https://jcpc.uk/uploads/jcpc_2018_0072_0096_judgment_76268b41d9.pdf), the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council dismissed the appeals on 25 October 2022. The proceedings concerned Russell Tesheira’s death after prostate surgery on 13 April 2004.

Paragraphs 8–10 record the trial decision and the subsequent appeal. The High Court assessed damages at TT$18,034,772.33, payable after deduction of the ex gratia sum paid by the surgeon who had settled separately. Paragraph 100 dismisses the appeals. The figure should therefore be identified as the assessed damages, not represented as a fresh 2022 award or as the net amount received.

The judgment addresses expert evidence, the findings of negligence and causation, including fluid overload. It does not create a compensation ceiling for future claims. See particularly paragraphs 95–100 and the factual and procedural history in the official judgment.

South West Regional Health Authority v Samdaye Harrilal

The Court of Appeal’s reasons, Civil Appeal 60 of 2008, delivered 12 May 2011, concern a stillbirth and medical care during industrial action. Paragraph 1 records that the court had dismissed the liability appeal on 25 January 2010 but allowed the damages appeal in part.

The Court of Appeal reduced general damages from TT$140,000 to TT$120,000. Paragraph 16 expressly states that there was no basis for exemplary damages and no evidential basis for the nervous-shock component. Paragraph 64 explains the TT$120,000 assessment. This decision supports careful separation of breach, causation and the losses proved.

Bhagwantee Singh-Weekes v South-West Regional Health Authority

The correct proceedings concerning Navin Singh are CV2015-02479, brought by Bhagwantee Singh-Weekes personally and as legal representative of his estate. The High Court liability judgment of 14 February 2020 concerns failure to diagnose necrotising fasciitis. Its concluding paragraphs explain the connection between delayed diagnosis, delayed treatment and his death.

The later Court of Appeal judgment, P271 of 2020, delivered 28 July 2023 must also be consulted when quoting compensation. Paragraphs 103–104 set out the revised calculation:

ComponentAmount recorded by the Court of Appeal
Pain and sufferingTT$35,000.00
Loss of expectation of lifeTT$25,000.00
Funeral expenses inclusive of interestTT$54,265.72
Lost yearsTT$1,640,499.90
Interest on pre-judgment loss of earningsTT$7,450.25
Total of those claimsTT$1,762,215.87

Paragraph 104 separately orders reimbursement of US$10,277.30 for expenses relating to Dr Mayer and addresses costs. Do not add that US-dollar sum to the TT-dollar total without identifying the different currency. The court also revised the interest calculation; this is one reason an earlier headline amount is insufficient.

Anthony Jordan v North Central Regional Health Authority

In Anthony Jordan v NCRHA, CV2012-03889, 2 June 2015, the court considered the consequences of negligent medical treatment after a motor accident. Paragraphs 219–221 distinguish the heads of compensation.

The orders include TT$375,000 for pain, suffering and loss of amenities, and TT$75,000 for loss of future pecuniary prospects. The latter is not an aggravated-damages award. Medical expenses, nursing and domestic assistance, nominal pre-trial earnings loss, interest and costs were dealt with separately. Some claimed future expenses were not awarded. The decision illustrates why the evidence for each head matters and why two figures alone should not be presented as the complete recovery.

Comparing Judgments, Settlements and Allegations

A settlement is an agreed resolution and may contain no admission of liability. A filed claim is an allegation, not a finding that negligence occurred. Pending litigation should not be placed in a table of decided awards or used to predict a future payout.

When comparing a judgment, identify its date, court, case number, later appeal, heads of loss, interest and costs. Check whether a figure includes future earnings, dependency or care rather than only pain and suffering. Neither the highest award in a small selection nor an aggregate settlement total establishes a tariff for another claim.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does a large award mean a similar injury will receive the same amount?

No. The proven consequences, financial evidence and relevant legal principles determine the assessment. The judgments above concern different claims and different heads of loss.

Can interest be assumed to be a fixed percentage?

No. Section 25 of the Supreme Court of Judicature Act, Chapter 4:01 provides a discretionary power to award pre-judgment interest. The Singh-Weekes appeal, paragraphs 62–65 illustrates how a rate and calculation may be revised. Have the applicable period and rate checked for the particular claim.

Where can I read the decisions?

The links above lead to the T&T Judiciary’s judgment repository and the Judicial Committee’s own judgment. Read the actual orders as well as the factual discussion, and check for subsequent proceedings before relying on a decision.

Filing Deadlines

For a personal-injury claim, section 5 of the Limitation of Certain Actions Act, Chapter 7:09 generally allows four years from accrual of the cause of action or the later date of qualifying knowledge. Section 7 governs knowledge, including knowledge reasonably obtainable. Statutory exceptions and the court’s discretion under section 9 may affect the result. Seek legal advice promptly to establish the applicable deadline; do not assume that a late claim is automatically permitted or inevitably barred. Fatal claims require separate consideration of sections 5 and 6 and the Compensation for Injuries Act, Chapter 8:05.

See our medical-negligence overview and medical-negligence services.

This article provides general legal information. For advice about your circumstances, contact Martin George & Company.