Medical Negligence in Trinidad and Tobago: When Healthcare Goes Wrong

Medical negligence in Trinidad and Tobago occurs when a healthcare professional — a doctor, nurse, hospital, or health authority — fails to provide treatment that meets the accepted standard of care, and that failure causes avoidable harm to the patient. For a personal-injury claim, section 5 of the Limitation of Certain Actions Act, Chapter 7:09 generally allows four years from accrual of the cause of action or the later date of qualifying knowledge. Section 7 governs knowledge, including knowledge reasonably obtainable. Statutory exceptions and the court’s discretion under section 9 may affect the result. Seek legal advice promptly to establish the applicable deadline; do not assume that a late claim is automatically permitted or inevitably barred.

What Is Medical Negligence?

Medical negligence is the improper or unskilled treatment of a patient by a healthcare professional resulting in harm, injury, or death. It is not simply a bad outcome — medicine involves uncertainty, and not every adverse result is the product of negligence. What the law requires is that the professional deviated from the standard of care that a reasonably competent practitioner in their field would have provided, and that deviation caused the patient's harm.

Three elements must be established:

Element What must be proved
Duty of care A doctor-patient (or nurse-patient, hospital-patient) relationship existed
Breach of standard The professional's conduct fell below the standard of a reasonably competent practitioner
Causation and harm The breach caused the patient's injury, illness, or death

All three must be proved. A breach of standard that caused no harm is not actionable. An adverse outcome from an inherent risk — properly explained and managed — is not negligence.

What Is the "Standard of Care"?

The standard of care is not perfection. It is the standard of a reasonably competent practitioner exercising ordinary skill and care in the relevant field. A general practitioner is assessed against the standard of a reasonably competent GP — not against the standard of a specialist. A specialist is assessed against the standard of a competent specialist in that field.

The standard is established by expert evidence — from a medical professional in the same or a related field — who explains what a reasonably competent practitioner would have done in the same circumstances.

What Are Common Examples of Medical Negligence in T&T?

  • Misdiagnosis or delayed diagnosis — failing to identify a condition that a competent practitioner would have detected, allowing it to progress and cause greater harm
  • Incorrect medication — prescribing the wrong drug, the wrong dose, or failing to check for known contraindications
  • Surgical errors — operating on the wrong site, leaving foreign objects in the body, or causing damage through improper technique
  • Improper prenatal or obstetric care — failure to monitor high-risk pregnancies, or mismanagement of labour and delivery
  • Failure to refer — a GP who fails to refer a patient to a specialist when the symptoms indicate the need
  • Failure to obtain informed consent — carrying out a procedure without properly explaining the risks and obtaining the patient's agreement

Are Hospitals Liable for Their Staff?

Yes. Regional Health Authorities in Trinidad and Tobago are liable for the negligent acts of their employed medical staff through vicarious liability: the employer is held responsible for wrongs committed by employees acting in the course of their employment.

For public-hospital matters, identify the responsible Regional Health Authority before making a records request, complaint or claim. The Ministry of Health’s RHA directory lists five authorities: North West, North Central, South-West, Eastern and Tobago. In particular, Caura Hospital is under the North Central RHA. The correct defendant and any additional parties depend on the facts; a facility name alone does not settle liability.

Suing a Private Hospital vs. a Regional Health Authority

The route to compensation differs depending on whether the negligence occurred at a public or private facility.

Regional Health Authorities (public facilities): Claims are brought against the relevant RHA as a statutory body. The RHA is fully liable for the negligent acts of its employed staff through vicarious liability. Because the State stands behind the RHA, judgment enforcement is generally not in question — but public facilities can be slower to respond to pre-action letters and more likely to defend than to settle early.

Private hospitals and clinics: Claims are brought against the clinic or hospital company and/or the individual practitioner. A private specialist who operates as an independent contractor at a private facility may bear personal liability separately from the facility. The private entity's insurance position matters — an uninsured private practitioner against whom judgment is obtained may have difficulty satisfying the award. Before committing to litigation against a private provider, establishing their liability insurance position through a lawyer is advisable.

The standard of care applied is identical in both settings. A public hospital does not receive a lower standard than a private one. The RHA context affects the procedural route, not the substantive test for negligence.

Reading Medical Negligence Awards

Compensation must be read against the actual judgment and any appeal. In SWRHA v Harrilal, Civil Appeal 60 of 2008, the Court of Appeal reduced damages to TT$120,000 and found no basis for exemplary damages. In Singh-Weekes v SWRHA, P271 of 2020, 28 July 2023, the court revised the compensation calculation and separately addressed expert expenses and costs.

See our case-by-case guide with official judgments for the components. Judgments are not guaranteed minimum payouts; settlements and filed allegations are different from findings of liability.

What the Law Says in Trinidad and Tobago: The Standard and the Cases

Medical negligence claims in T&T are founded in the general law of negligence — the principles first articulated in Donoghue v Stevenson [1932] AC 562 and developed through Caribbean and English case law. There is no dedicated medical negligence statute in T&T. The claim is a tort action brought in the High Court under ordinary negligence principles.

The standard of care for medical professionals is assessed according to the Bolam test (from Bolam v Friern Hospital Management Committee [1957] 1 WLR 583), which holds that a professional is not negligent if they acted in accordance with a practice accepted as proper by a responsible body of practitioners in the same field. T&T courts also follow the House of Lords’ refinement in Bolitho v City and Hackney Health Authority [1997] 3 WLR 1151, which requires that the practice relied upon be capable of withstanding logical analysis.

Samdaye Harrilal v South West Regional Health Authority

The claimant was admitted to San Fernando General Hospital and gave birth to a stillborn child on April 23, 2002. No obstetrician was on duty — senior medical staff were engaged in industrial action. A high-risk patient with a congenital heart condition was never seen by a doctor during her admission. The Court of Appeal upheld liability and awarded TT$120,000, establishing that the absence of appropriate specialist cover — even during industrial action — does not excuse the hospital authority from its duty to patients.

Bhagwantee Singh-Weekes v South-West Regional Health Authority

The High Court liability judgment, CV2015-02479, 14 February 2020, found that delayed diagnosis and treatment of necrotising fasciitis led to Navin Singh’s death. His mother brought the proceedings personally and as legal representative of his estate. The Court of Appeal’s 28 July 2023 judgment, paragraphs 103–104, revised the total of the specified claims to TT$1,762,215.87, with expert expenses and costs dealt with separately. Check the appellate orders when quoting the outcome.

How to Obtain Your Medical Records from a Regional Health Authority

This is the first practical step in any medical negligence assessment — and the one most patients do not know how to take. Your medical records are essential for establishing what treatment was given, when, and by whom.

How to request your records:

  1. Submit a written request to the Medical Records Department of the relevant Regional Health Authority. Address the letter to the Chief Executive Officer of the RHA with a copy to the Medical Records Department.
  2. Identify yourself clearly — full name, date of birth, NIN, and the date(s) of treatment.
  3. Specify what records you need: consultation notes, investigation results, admission records, discharge summaries, operative notes, prescription records.
  4. Include a copy of a photo ID.
  5. The RHA has a duty to respond. The Freedom of Information Act, Chapter 22:02 provides a legal right to access records held by public authorities including health authorities.

If records are not provided: Follow up in writing with reference to your original request and the Freedom of Information Act. If you are denied access without adequate reason, an attorney can write formally on your behalf. Records withheld or delayed when litigation is anticipated may also be the subject of a court disclosure order.

Note the limitation period. While you gather records and seek advice, the four-year clock continues to run. Do not let the process of assembling information cause you to miss the deadline for filing.

Fatal Cases: When Medical Negligence Causes Death

Where medical negligence causes the death of the patient, the claim does not end with the patient. The estate of the deceased can bring a claim for the losses suffered before death — pain, suffering, and loss of amenity. Dependants of the deceased may also bring a separate claim under the Compensation for Injuries Act, Chapter 8:05 for the financial loss they suffer as a result of the death. Both claims can be brought together. Legal advice on the appropriate heads of claim is essential in fatal cases.

How to Build a Medical Negligence Claim: A Practical Sequence

Step 1 — Preserve all medical records. Request copies of all relevant records, test results, prescriptions, discharge summaries, operative notes, and referral letters as soon as possible. Use the FOI Act process described above. Records become harder to obtain as time passes and are sometimes altered or lost.

Step 2 — Note every relevant date. Record treatment, injury and when you learned the relevant facts. For a personal-injury claim, section 5 of the Limitation of Certain Actions Act, Chapter 7:09 generally allows four years from accrual of the cause of action or the later date of qualifying knowledge. Section 7 governs knowledge, including knowledge reasonably obtainable. Ask your attorney to assess the dates and any applicable exception immediately.

Step 3 — Instruct a lawyer experienced in medical negligence. Medical negligence is a specialist litigation area. A lawyer with experience in this field will know how to obtain medical records, how to instruct expert witnesses, and how to draft a Letter of Claim that puts the defendant on notice while preserving your legal position.

Step 4 — Obtain independent medical expert evidence. Every medical negligence claim requires an expert to assess the records and provide a written opinion on whether the standard of care was breached. The expert must be a practitioner in the same or a closely related field. Without a credible expert opinion supporting the claim, it cannot be advanced.

Step 5 — Send a Letter of Claim. Before filing court proceedings, your lawyer will send a formal Letter of Claim to the defendant (or the relevant RHA) setting out the factual basis of the negligence, the harm caused, and the quantum of loss claimed. Many medical negligence claims in T&T settle at this stage without the need for trial.

Step 6 — File High Court proceedings if not settled. If the defendant does not respond adequately or settlement cannot be reached, a claim is filed in the High Court. Medical negligence cases in T&T typically take several years from filing to trial — expert evidence, disclosure of records, and court scheduling all contribute to the timeline.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is medical negligence in Trinidad and Tobago?

Medical negligence is the failure of a healthcare professional to provide treatment meeting the accepted standard of care, resulting in avoidable harm to the patient. Three things must be proved: a duty of care existed, the professional's conduct fell below the standard of a reasonably competent practitioner, and that breach caused the patient's harm or death. A bad outcome alone — without a breach of the standard — does not constitute negligence.

Can I sue a public hospital in Trinidad and Tobago?

Yes. Regional Health Authorities — including the NWRHA, NCRHA, SWRHA, ERHA, and TRHA — are liable for the negligent acts of their employed staff. Claims against public hospitals are brought against the relevant Regional Health Authority. The same standard of care applies as to private facilities. See the official judgments linked above for decided claims and their outcomes.

How long do I have to make a medical negligence claim in Trinidad and Tobago?

For a personal-injury claim, section 5 of the Limitation of Certain Actions Act, Chapter 7:09 generally allows four years from accrual of the cause of action or the later date of qualifying knowledge. Section 7 governs knowledge, including knowledge reasonably obtainable. Statutory exceptions and the court’s discretion under section 9 may affect the result. Seek legal advice promptly to establish the applicable deadline; do not assume that a late claim is automatically permitted or inevitably barred.

How do I get my medical records from the hospital in Trinidad and Tobago?

Submit a written request to the Medical Records Department of the relevant Regional Health Authority, addressed to the CEO with a copy to the Medical Records Department. Identify yourself fully, specify the dates of treatment, and list the records you need. Include a copy of photo ID. The Freedom of Information Act, Chapter 22:02 provides a legal right to access records held by public health authorities. If records are withheld, an attorney can assist with formal demand or a court disclosure application.

How much compensation can I receive for medical negligence in T&T?

There is no fixed scale. Compensation depends on the losses proved and the applicable heads of damage. The official judgments linked above distinguish personal injury, estate losses, interest and costs. Obtain advice on the particular claim rather than treating another award as a guaranteed result.

Can a misdiagnosis be the basis of a medical negligence claim?

Yes. If a doctor failed to diagnose a condition that a reasonably competent practitioner would have identified, and the failure caused the patient's harm to worsen or become fatal, a misdiagnosis can found a medical negligence claim. The Singh-Weekes judgments linked above illustrate the need to establish breach, causation and the particular losses claimed.


This article provides general legal information. For advice about your circumstances, contact Martin George & Company.