Quantum of Damages in Motor Vehicle Collisions in Trinidad and Tobago: How Courts Calculate What You Are Owed

Quantum means the amount of compensation. It requires proof of the losses caused by the actionable wrong; a diagnosis alone does not establish a fixed payout. The assessment should distinguish non-financial injury, past financial loss, future loss, interest and costs, while avoiding double counting.

The Cornilliac Assessment Factors

Cornilliac v St Louis (1965) 7 WIR 491 identifies five assessment factors. They are reproduced in Anthony Jordan v NCRHA, CV2012-03889, paragraph 13:

  1. The nature and extent of the injuries.
  2. The nature and gravity of resulting physical disability.
  3. Pain and suffering endured.
  4. Loss of amenities.
  5. The effect on pecuniary prospects.

These factors guide assessment; they are not six separate automatic payments. Past financial expenses must also be pleaded and supported under the appropriate heads. Jordan concerns negligent treatment following a motor accident, so its damages should not be attributed wholesale to the original collision.

General Damages and Comparable Decisions

The court considers the medical evidence and the effect on the particular claimant. Relevant comparisons require attention to injury, recovery, disability, activities affected and the date of the earlier award. A comparable diagnosis does not necessarily mean a comparable financial loss.

The analysis in Jordan, paragraphs 13–26 and 219–221 shows the importance of identifying what harm the defendant actually caused and distinguishing it from the original injury. It also separates pain and suffering from effects on future pecuniary prospects.

An attorney should identify the specific decisions supporting an estimate and explain the differences. A broad online range for “whiplash”, “fracture” or “catastrophic injury” should not be treated as a court-approved tariff, minimum or maximum.

Past Financial Loss and Supporting Records

Keep medical bills, receipts, wage records, employer correspondence and evidence of other losses. For a vehicle claim, preserve photographs, valuations, repair estimates and invoices. These records help establish the amount, timing and connection to the incident.

Claims must distinguish sums actually incurred from estimates and future expenses. The Jordan judgment’s discussion of special damages and final orders illustrates that the amount claimed and the amount proved can be very different. Where exact proof is difficult, seek advice about the evidence available rather than assuming the court will accept an unsupported total.

Future Earnings and Care

Future losses depend on evidence about continuing disability, likely work capacity, treatment and support needs. A calculation may use an annual loss and an appropriate multiplier, but neither the annual sum nor the remaining years to retirement should be assumed without analysis. Relevant contingencies and the form of the award matter.

The Singh-Weekes appeal, P271 of 2020, 28 July 2023 illustrates judicial scrutiny of earnings assumptions and calculation. It is a fatal medical-negligence case, not a motor-injury tariff. Jordan separately demonstrates an award for loss of future pecuniary prospects and rejection of some future-expense claims. Have the correct method selected for the facts and evidence of your claim.

For care needs, retain medical recommendations and itemised cost estimates. Distinguish care already provided, future care, replacement equipment and treatment. Do not count the same loss under more than one heading.

Interest and Costs

Section 25 of the Supreme Court of Judicature Act, Chapter 4:01 allows the court to include pre-judgment interest at a rate and for a period it considers appropriate, subject to the statutory limits. It does not prescribe a universal 3%–6% personal-injury rate.

The Singh-Weekes appeal, paragraphs 62–65 revised an interest calculation. Rates used in a historical judgment are not promises about a current claim. Distinguish interest on past losses, treatment of future loss and post-judgment interest when assessing an offer or order.

Legal costs are also distinct from damages. An order for costs does not necessarily reimburse every amount a client has agreed to pay an attorney. The same appeal, paragraphs 99–104 discusses that distinction.

Fatal Claims

Death can give rise to different causes of action, including estate and dependency claims. The Compensation for Injuries Act, Chapter 8:05 governs the statutory fatal-injury action. Eligibility, representation, the heads of loss and possible overlap require specific advice. A dependency total should not be placed in a table labelled general damages for personal injury.

Filing Deadlines

For a personal-injury claim, section 5 of the Limitation of Certain Actions Act, Chapter 7:09 generally allows four years from accrual of the cause of action or the later date of qualifying knowledge. Section 7 governs knowledge, including knowledge reasonably obtainable. Statutory exceptions and the court’s discretion under section 9 may affect the result. Seek legal advice promptly to establish the applicable deadline; do not assume that a late claim is automatically permitted or inevitably barred. Fatal claims require separate consideration of sections 5 and 6 and the Compensation for Injuries Act, Chapter 8:05.

Preparing for a Consultation

Bring a chronology, accident and police documents, medical records, photographs, income evidence and expense records. Identify ongoing symptoms, work restrictions and assistance needed. Ask for an assessment that explains the evidence, comparable decisions and uncertainties for each head of loss.

Is there a guaranteed range for my injury?

No. A useful estimate should be supported by relevant judgments and your evidence, with liability issues and each head of loss identified. The amount another person recovered is not a guaranteed result.

Should I wait for complete recovery before obtaining advice?

No. Obtain advice promptly about preservation of evidence, the filing deadline and how to assess future loss. Ongoing treatment does not itself suspend the limitation period.

See our motor-vehicle accident guide and personal-injury services.

This article provides general legal information. For advice about your circumstances, contact Martin George & Company.